We know that our brains are not fully formed and fully operational until we’re in our mid- to late-20s. This fact hit home to me when I tried to remember the name of a Unitarian minister in Belmont, MA, where I grew up.
I joined the youth group at the First Church of Belmont, MA (Unitarian) after escaping from one of the local Catholic church Christian Conference (read: indoctrination) weekly classes in a fit of pique with the youth priest. I never did go back. The Unitarian church’s youth group had an advisor named Bill Ramsden, who wowed us with radical interpretations of Bible stories. Our youth group came together in multiple powerful ways, one of which was singing. We ultimately became the strong core of the church’s choir and did a remarkable job preparing the Fauré Requiem and singing it for the congregation and elsewhere at least once. My defecting to a Protestant church was even more remarkable, given the injunction of the Catholic church of the time never to cross the threshold of a Protestant church, under pain of possible immediate death or, at the least, shriveling of the soul. My personal response was exhilaration.
The minister of First Church of Belmont was Rev. John Nicholls Booth. I found him forbidding and kind of grim. He was a very good-looking man, with a strong pulpit (pulpit?? This was something new!) presence. His sermons were a revelation: we weren’t constantly reminded of our originally sinful nature and general rottenness, which, for horny Catholic youth required frequent confession to unburden us. I was amazed. But I was also taken aback by his forceful presentation.
That was the impression of a 14-year-old brain. I was having fun with that cool youth minister. I could noodle on the church organ when I wanted to, was scooting around the town on my bicycle, playing soccer at my high school, doing things an adolescent would do – and, by the way, pretty much thinking as an adolescent would, though my insistent disagreement with the priest at the Catholic church where I grew up indicated a kernel of maturity that would grow, despite the hormones and the youthful confusion.
It’s telling about how our brains work that my adolescent impression of John Nicholls Booth persisted to the recent day when I read a Unitarian Universalist Ministers Association memory of Booth. It was a revelation. And it abruptly expunged that old, lurking memory.
Rev. Booth died in 2009 at age 97. I was surprised to learn that he began his Unitarian ministry in 1942 at the Unitarian Church of Evanston, just a few miles from where I live now. Belmont was his second stop.
The Ministers Association memory reveals that Booth was also a professional magician who wrote influential books on magic; a film producer; and a journalist, serving on sabbatical in 1948 as the Chicago Sun-Times Asiatic Correspondent, interviewing the prime ministers of Japan, China, Thailand and India, among many others – all before I knew him starting in 1954.
Had I had more sense and less baggage (I suspect that my impression of Booth was a lagging indicator of my memories of forbidding priests and nuns), I’d have tried to have gotten to know John Nicholls Booth as something other than a possible ogre.
It makes me wonder how many memories from that early part of life lurk in the recesses of my hippocampus, maligning perfectly decent people, making me dislike certain foods, repelled by a piece of art that shocked me.
I loved classical music from before my early teens. I was enthralled by Beethoven, Schubert, Brahms, Chopin, Fauré, Saint-Saëns, Haydn, Gershwin, and many others. I was not at all enthralled with Ives, Hindemith, Stravinsky, Honnegger, or composers of that sort.
Years later, I heard a piece of music on my local classical music station, loving it and finding out, to my surprise, that it was Hindemith’s Mathis der Maler. In my graduate studies in English, I wrote a long, very well-received paper on Charles Ives (whose music I had come to love), Wallace Stevens and William Carlos Williams that concerned itself with their all being avocational artists, making their livings doing other things: Ives owned an insurance agency in New York City, Stevens was a lawyer and vice president at Hartford Accident and Indemnity Company, and Williams was a pediatrician in Rutherford, New Jersey.
Of course, my interest in those avocational artists was self-reflecting. Here I was, both in graduate school and working at an insurance company my own self, reveling in the stories of these giants of art and their double lives. Full-on maturity takes time and follows strange paths.
But I digress. That callow youth who looked down from the choir loft, placing the man in the pulpit in the pantheon of perpetual perdition, reappeared ever so briefly recently, rising in memory only to be shown the door. We hope.
Edmund J. McDevitt
© November 2026
